Elvie vs. Willow Go – I Tried Them Both So You Don’t Have to (2023 Comparison Review)
Hey momma, I see you looking for the best wearable pump for your feeding journey. No matter if you’re exceptional pumping or on the lookout for a thing to complement breastfeeding, I’m listed here to help. I’ve attempted six distinct pumps like the wearables – the Elvie and the Willow Go. Here’s everything to know about how they stack up from every single other and which you should really obtain.
By the way, I paid out whole rate for both of those of these pumps, so this is a truly impartial evaluate. Let’s review each and every of the crucial features under to aid you come to a decision what is most essential.
Ease and comfort/Healthy
I’m a supporter of the two pumps for the ease and comfort and the healthy. Every single can healthy into a nursing bra, or even a normal comfortable bra, devoid of forcing me to modify into a pumping bra like a common pump would.
The Willow Go is bigger at 5.3″ x 3.1″ x 4.7″, weighing 13.6oz. The Elvie is 5″ x 4.3″ x 2.7″ and weighs 7.4oz. The bodyweight variance is only noticeable for me if I use the Elvie for a 7 days or additional and switch back again to the Willow Go. I locate them the two basic enough to healthy to the nipple, however there is a large big difference when it will come to flange size.
The Elvie comes with 24 and 28mm flanges. For me and several ladies like me, the two of people are too massive. You can purchase a 21mm flange, or off-manufacturer flange inserts to make it even smaller sized. Sadly the Elvie does not provide just about anything scaled-down than 21mm. While it is continue to workable with off-brand name inserts, it would operate even much better with inserts or flanges manufactured by Elvie for the pump, so this is a ding for me.
The Willow Go arrives with 21mm and 24mm flanges as well as a valuable sizing sheet and tutorial. I nonetheless experienced to obtain the 19mm inserts separately, but because they’re Willow brand name they suit securely and I do not have to sacrifice any suction.
If you do go with the Elvie and want smaller sized inserts, I propose the Willow ones as they’re softer and nicer than the Maymom manufacturer.
Winner: Willow Go.
Suction
A persistent rumor with wearable pumps is that they don’t empty the breast. I haven’t found this to be real for me. In the starting, I employed a clinic grade pump and after it was time to return it, transitioned to wearable pumps exclusively because I despise time-out and I get far better output with them than my Spectra, believe it or not. However some people today do see a dip in output.
This could be thanks to the decrease suction made available by wearable pumps vs. a plug-in, while the Willow Go boasts clinic-quality suction at 280mmHG, and the Elvie is 220mmHG. To me this is irrelevant mainly because I can not go that large comfortably.
Winner: Willow Go has higher suction abilities.
Discreetness
Can we agree that there is no way for a wearable pump to be truly discreet, considering that it has to make at minimum some sound and have to have home for the motor and milk catchment?
Both pumps will make you show up to attain 7 cup measurements. Your outfit decisions will make all the change below!
Some complain that the Elvie has lights that will glow by a shirt. Whilst genuine, if you are sporting some thing that thin and type-fitting, the jig will be up possibly way. I uncover a scarf or unfastened jacket solves the visibility difficulty of each.
Nonetheless the Elvie is a great deal quieter. The Elvie can also be controlled by an app although the Willow Go can not, forcing me to get to into my shirt to change the suction.
Winner: Elvie.
The App
There is no contest listed here. The Elvie app will monitor your pumps, measure your output in serious time, and permit you to management the pump from your cellular phone. This is so useful for those people of us with mother brain — which is absolutely everyone, certainly? — who can not try to remember when we very last pumped or what we obtained.
I simply cannot fathom what the issue is of the Willow Go application, which has a sea of 1-star opinions. It’s effectively a timer with no other capabilities. My principle is Willow would instead not give it all the bells and whistles so that there is even now a cause to pay for the much more high priced Willow 3., which has a much more robust app.
Winner: Elvie by Much.
Battery Everyday living
Both of those pumps past me five to 6 pumping sessions, and both equally are chargeable with a USB charger. Equally just take about two hours to achieve a entire charge, though in a pinch you can nevertheless demand partially and pump with possibly a single.
If you are finding the battery existence sucks, access out to purchaser company for a alternative. It shouldn’t be necessary to charge right after every pump.
Winner: Tie.
Spilling/Leakage
As any pumping mama is familiar with – we cry in excess of spilled milk! I would like I could say neither pump has a difficulty with this, but equally of them do. Until you’re pumping with the Willow 3. and applying the one-use luggage, which are no good friend to the earth and involve constant re-buying, you are going to have to be mindful about bending in excess of, and you unquestionably can’t lie down to pump.
The Elvie at times leaks when I’m pumping, specially if I have stuffed a container and bend more than as well considerably. The gauge generally catches it prior to this transpires, but if it does not, I have a wet bra which is annoying as hell.
The Willow Go’s issue is with pouring the milk out of the pump and into a bottle or storage bag. I pretty much generally lost some in the beginning while I have gotten the hang of it now.
Nonetheless, there is got to be a far better way to style the two to steer clear of spillage.
Winner: No one wins here!
Pieces and Cleansing
Each pumps have an equal total of areas that you will have to clean up. Both of those pump sections can go in the dishwasher and I don’t discover both just one to be tough to cleanse. Having said that the Elvie arrives with two more milk containers for effortless storage and considerably less frequent cleaning.
Owing to the style and design of the Willow Go, you have to empty the milk each time into a further container in order to use it yet again. I discover this irritating and greatly want the Elvie’s milk catchment process.
Warranty
The Elvie pulls in advance with a two calendar year guarantee compared to the Willow Go’s 1 yr. There’s nothing more frustrating than jogging into an concern a handful of months soon after your a single-year guarantee runs out.
Winner: Elvie
Pricing
This is definitely a substantial one. The Willow Go is presently $329 whilst Elvie is $549.99. If you have to have a 21mm flange, you can also add that to the cost of the Elvie.
The massive dilemma is no matter if it is worthy of the more $220.99 for the Elvie.
My Pick
As an special pumper who only uses the wearable pumps, I have been extremely happy to have both equally. There have been times when I forgot an important section when on a flight and was glad to have back again up, did not want to clean the areas although out and about and however had a clean selection when I obtained household, or experienced a single run out of battery.
I comprehend most people will want to just acquire one particular or the other. The remedy relies upon on how vital the application monitoring and management, quieter mother nature of the Elvie, additional containers/fewer recurrent cleansing, and more time guarantee are for you.
Knowing what I know now, if I have been to purchase a person, I would in all probability decide on the Willow Go given that it’s more cost-effective. The application is annoying, but I have learned to reside with it.
I hope this comparison helped you figure out which a single would be finest for YOU.
Got inquiries? Truly feel cost-free to drop them in the reviews beneath.
Touring with your child quickly? Here’s a free of charge infant journey packing listing for you:
*If you decide on to purchase both pump by means of my affiliate inbound links, you support me and this internet site at no additional price to you. Thanks for looking at and helping us do what we do!